Home
News
In Focus
Business
Metro
Nation
World
Sports
Feature
Opinion
View more »Opinion Columns
Wan LixinOpinion deputy editor of Shanghai Daily
Forum emphasizes BRI cooperation between China and Arab countries
Rights to lower sleeper berths should be softened by empathy for fellow passengers
Sunday
- Subscribe
Related News
Home » Opinion » Foreign Views
World Bank: Don't fret about China's wage hikes
By Louis Kuijs |
June 23, 2010, Wednesday
|
Print Edition
Print Edition
THE World Bank released its latest Quarterly Update on China's economy on Friday (for disclosure's sake: I'm the lead author).
At the press launch, there were a lot of questions about the recent wage hikes in several foreign-owned manufacturing companies and the possible concerns these have triggered among many about possible loss of competitiveness and/or a wage-inflation spiral.
There were also, as usual, quite a few questions about the exchange rate.
Meanwhile, the People's Bank of China over the weekend announced the plan to re-introduce more flexibility in the exchange rate regime, after almost two years of a de facto peg to the US dollar. This is likely to set the stage for a stronger exchange rate over time.
I would argue that the timing of the move on the exchange rate suggests that China's authorities broadly agree that, overall, the outlook on exports, growth, and competitiveness in China is fairly good.
In our view, economic developments have largely been favorable. Growth has been strong, with some softening recently.
Real estate construction has been an important driver of growth while consumption has held up well, reflecting a healthy labor market.
Export volumes have recovered rapidly since the trough in early 2009. Indeed, they have grown faster than world imports, resulting in further market gains, reflecting the strong fundamental competitiveness of China's manufacturing industry.
In all, growth has become less reliant on stimulus. Government-led investment has slowed substantially and overall investment has also slowed.
More recently, leading indicators and industrial production data suggest that activity is decelerating somewhat.
Inflation has picked up because of food prices and housing related costs, but core inflation remains low.
One area where the situation is complicated is real estate. Property prices rose very rapidly in much of 2009 and the first part of 2010. That was unsustainable.
The government took measures to contain these price rises, emphasizing tightening the access to mortgage financing. The government did not really want to see real estate activity slow dramatically.
But that is what some are now afraid of, and that underlines the challenges in this part of the economy.
In all, we project 9.5 percent GDP growth for 2010 and 8.5 percent for 2011.
In terms of the composition, growth is going to be less driven by investment this year and benefit from more favorable external trade.
Consumption is likely to remain supported by a strong labor market, which boosts household incomes and confidence.
Under China's pattern of growth, increases in supply are large compared to increases in demand. And despite substantial wage growth in the recent decade, unit labor cost (ULC) increases in manufacturing have remained low, because of rapid productivity growth and upgrading. It is not obvious that this is going to change rapidly.
What about the large wage increases recently? This is in large part a cyclical issue, reflecting the strong rebound in the labor market after an earlier downturn last year when wage growth slowed.
When you look at the recent increases in factory wages or the minimum wages over a two-year horizon, they are not far of historical norms.
It is likely that the recent wage hikes encourage higher wages elsewhere. How individual companies will respond will vary.
However, given the track record of manufacturing to keep ULC growth under control and the flexibility of the labor market, it still seems unlikely to me that a worrisome wage-inflation spiral will result from this.
What about structural trends? The recent wage increases take place against a backdrop of discussions about the possible exhaustion of China's surplus labor.
When a large part of the labor force is working in agriculture, at low incomes, rising demand for labor from industry can be met without high wage increases.
Once all the surplus labor is absorbed, rising demand will lead to larger wage increases. This is the time in a country's stage of development that we start to see significant sustained real exchange rate (RER) appreciation.
China does not yet seem to be at the stage where surplus labor is exhausted and this leads to a structural tightening of the labor market and RER appreciation.
In principle it is possible that things are different in China, maybe because demographic changes associated with aging will affect the country at a relatively early stage of development, compared to other countries.
However, looking at the timing and pace of these upcoming demographic trends and observing that there are still large numbers of people working in low productivity activities and receiving low incomes, both in the country side and in cities, this type of sustained tightening of the labor is not yet likely to take place in the coming years.
(The author is a senior economist at the World Bank's China office. Reprinted with permission from the World Bank. Shanghai Daily condensed the article.)
At the press launch, there were a lot of questions about the recent wage hikes in several foreign-owned manufacturing companies and the possible concerns these have triggered among many about possible loss of competitiveness and/or a wage-inflation spiral.
There were also, as usual, quite a few questions about the exchange rate.
Meanwhile, the People's Bank of China over the weekend announced the plan to re-introduce more flexibility in the exchange rate regime, after almost two years of a de facto peg to the US dollar. This is likely to set the stage for a stronger exchange rate over time.
I would argue that the timing of the move on the exchange rate suggests that China's authorities broadly agree that, overall, the outlook on exports, growth, and competitiveness in China is fairly good.
In our view, economic developments have largely been favorable. Growth has been strong, with some softening recently.
Real estate construction has been an important driver of growth while consumption has held up well, reflecting a healthy labor market.
Export volumes have recovered rapidly since the trough in early 2009. Indeed, they have grown faster than world imports, resulting in further market gains, reflecting the strong fundamental competitiveness of China's manufacturing industry.
In all, growth has become less reliant on stimulus. Government-led investment has slowed substantially and overall investment has also slowed.
More recently, leading indicators and industrial production data suggest that activity is decelerating somewhat.
Inflation has picked up because of food prices and housing related costs, but core inflation remains low.
One area where the situation is complicated is real estate. Property prices rose very rapidly in much of 2009 and the first part of 2010. That was unsustainable.
The government took measures to contain these price rises, emphasizing tightening the access to mortgage financing. The government did not really want to see real estate activity slow dramatically.
But that is what some are now afraid of, and that underlines the challenges in this part of the economy.
In all, we project 9.5 percent GDP growth for 2010 and 8.5 percent for 2011.
In terms of the composition, growth is going to be less driven by investment this year and benefit from more favorable external trade.
Consumption is likely to remain supported by a strong labor market, which boosts household incomes and confidence.
Under China's pattern of growth, increases in supply are large compared to increases in demand. And despite substantial wage growth in the recent decade, unit labor cost (ULC) increases in manufacturing have remained low, because of rapid productivity growth and upgrading. It is not obvious that this is going to change rapidly.
What about the large wage increases recently? This is in large part a cyclical issue, reflecting the strong rebound in the labor market after an earlier downturn last year when wage growth slowed.
When you look at the recent increases in factory wages or the minimum wages over a two-year horizon, they are not far of historical norms.
It is likely that the recent wage hikes encourage higher wages elsewhere. How individual companies will respond will vary.
However, given the track record of manufacturing to keep ULC growth under control and the flexibility of the labor market, it still seems unlikely to me that a worrisome wage-inflation spiral will result from this.
What about structural trends? The recent wage increases take place against a backdrop of discussions about the possible exhaustion of China's surplus labor.
When a large part of the labor force is working in agriculture, at low incomes, rising demand for labor from industry can be met without high wage increases.
Once all the surplus labor is absorbed, rising demand will lead to larger wage increases. This is the time in a country's stage of development that we start to see significant sustained real exchange rate (RER) appreciation.
China does not yet seem to be at the stage where surplus labor is exhausted and this leads to a structural tightening of the labor market and RER appreciation.
In principle it is possible that things are different in China, maybe because demographic changes associated with aging will affect the country at a relatively early stage of development, compared to other countries.
However, looking at the timing and pace of these upcoming demographic trends and observing that there are still large numbers of people working in low productivity activities and receiving low incomes, both in the country side and in cities, this type of sustained tightening of the labor is not yet likely to take place in the coming years.
(The author is a senior economist at the World Bank's China office. Reprinted with permission from the World Bank. Shanghai Daily condensed the article.)
- About Us
- |
- Terms of Use
- |
-
RSS - |
- Privacy Policy
- |
- Contact Us
- |
- Shanghai Call Center: 962288
- |
- Tip-off hotline: 52920043
- 沪ICP证：沪ICP备05050403号-1
- |
- 互联网新闻信息服务许可证：31120180004
- |
- 网络视听许可证：0909346
- |
- 广播电视节目制作许可证：沪字第354号
- |
- 增值电信业务经营许可证：沪B2-20120012
Copyright © 1999- Shanghai Daily. All rights reserved.Preferably viewed with Internet Explorer 8 or newer browsers.
