Home » Opinion » Chinese Views
Road isn't straight for new laws surrounding drunk driving
Source: Xinhua |
May 19, 2011, Thursday
|
Print Edition
Print Edition
Editor's note:
Musician Gao Xiaosong was sentenced to six months in jail on Tuesday for drunk driving- a perfect implementation of the amended Criminal Law that lists drunk driving as a criminal offense.
More than two weeks after the amended Criminal Law took effect, which stipulates that drunk driving is a criminal offense, the Chinese public and legal experts are still debating the amendments.
The amended Criminal Law stipulates that all drunk-driving incidents are considered criminal offenses, even if the act of drunk driving itself does not result in a traffic accident.
But Supreme People's Court (SPC) Vice President Zhang Jun said courts should "avoid generalizing such a conviction." Zhang said that a conviction should not be solely based on whether the incident meets the criteria of drunk driving.
According to the recently revised Criminal Law, if hazardous behavior is insignificant and causes slight harm, it will not be considered as a criminal offense, said Zhang.
Some say Zhang's comments challenge the integrity of the amendments and provide a loophole for drunk drivers who should be punished in line with the amended law.
A newly amended Road Traffic Safety Law, which also took effect on May 1, states that anyone caught drunk driving will have their driving license revoked. Drunk drivers will also need to wait five years to apply for a new license and face a detention period of one to six months under the amended law.
The earlier version of the law imposed a license suspension of only three to six months for drunk drivers. In order to help courts better handle specific drunk-driving cases, the SPC on Monday ordered lower courts submit it their first two closed trial judgments of drunk drivers convicted of criminal offenses, which would be "taken as a reference when dealing with such cases."
Gao Mingxuan, a law expert, said that when discussing the Criminal Law amendments last year, some people believed making all kinds of drunk driving a criminal offense was "too harsh," but others insisted that such a move was needed to deter people from driving under the influence of alcohol.
Gao said more specific judicial explanations or guidance should be published to help judges correctly determine drunk-driving cases.
Leniency
Chen Zexian, director of the Institute of International Law under the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, said making all cases of drunk driving a criminal offense was not in line with the country's judicial principle of "severity with leniency."
"Different drunk-driving cases that cause different levels of social harm should not be treated indiscriminately," Chen said, adding that as to those drivers slightly over the blood-alcohol limit and whose actions did little social harm, an administrative punishment was enough, and this also could save judicial resources.
According to the current law, drivers who have at least 80 milligrams of alcohol per 100 milliliters of blood in their body are considered drunk.
Drinking culture
As one of the largest producers of alcohol, China's drinking culture is well entrenched.
Government statistics show that China has more than 200 million drivers, with nearly 68,000 people killed in road accidents in 2009.
In a China Youth Daily survey, 99.6 percent of people surveyed admitted that members of their family or friends had at some stage driven while drunk.
In recent years, fatal car accidents in Chinese cities have triggered public outcry and rage, with many people calling for stricter penalties for drunk driving.
In July 2009, the Intermediate People's Court of Chengdu in Sichuan Province sentenced a drunk driver named Sun Weiming to death following an auto accident in which he was driving without a license and killed four people, which was the first such verdict in China.
In the second trial, the verdict was changed to life imprisonment.
Sun's case was deemed as "a crime against public security."
In the same month, a drunk driver in Nanjing, capital city of eastern Jiangsu Province, hit nine pedestrians and six cars, leaving five dead including a pregnant woman.
In contrast to the public's call for a tough penalty, the maximum sentence handed out was only a three-year prison term. The judges were constrained by the Criminal Law as it stood then.
Following the cases, the SPC issued a judicial interpretation in September 2009 that instructed local courts in what situations severe sentences should be given to a drunk driver.
Musician Gao Xiaosong was sentenced to six months in jail on Tuesday for drunk driving- a perfect implementation of the amended Criminal Law that lists drunk driving as a criminal offense.
More than two weeks after the amended Criminal Law took effect, which stipulates that drunk driving is a criminal offense, the Chinese public and legal experts are still debating the amendments.
The amended Criminal Law stipulates that all drunk-driving incidents are considered criminal offenses, even if the act of drunk driving itself does not result in a traffic accident.
But Supreme People's Court (SPC) Vice President Zhang Jun said courts should "avoid generalizing such a conviction." Zhang said that a conviction should not be solely based on whether the incident meets the criteria of drunk driving.
According to the recently revised Criminal Law, if hazardous behavior is insignificant and causes slight harm, it will not be considered as a criminal offense, said Zhang.
Some say Zhang's comments challenge the integrity of the amendments and provide a loophole for drunk drivers who should be punished in line with the amended law.
A newly amended Road Traffic Safety Law, which also took effect on May 1, states that anyone caught drunk driving will have their driving license revoked. Drunk drivers will also need to wait five years to apply for a new license and face a detention period of one to six months under the amended law.
The earlier version of the law imposed a license suspension of only three to six months for drunk drivers. In order to help courts better handle specific drunk-driving cases, the SPC on Monday ordered lower courts submit it their first two closed trial judgments of drunk drivers convicted of criminal offenses, which would be "taken as a reference when dealing with such cases."
Gao Mingxuan, a law expert, said that when discussing the Criminal Law amendments last year, some people believed making all kinds of drunk driving a criminal offense was "too harsh," but others insisted that such a move was needed to deter people from driving under the influence of alcohol.
Gao said more specific judicial explanations or guidance should be published to help judges correctly determine drunk-driving cases.
Leniency
Chen Zexian, director of the Institute of International Law under the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, said making all cases of drunk driving a criminal offense was not in line with the country's judicial principle of "severity with leniency."
"Different drunk-driving cases that cause different levels of social harm should not be treated indiscriminately," Chen said, adding that as to those drivers slightly over the blood-alcohol limit and whose actions did little social harm, an administrative punishment was enough, and this also could save judicial resources.
According to the current law, drivers who have at least 80 milligrams of alcohol per 100 milliliters of blood in their body are considered drunk.
Drinking culture
As one of the largest producers of alcohol, China's drinking culture is well entrenched.
Government statistics show that China has more than 200 million drivers, with nearly 68,000 people killed in road accidents in 2009.
In a China Youth Daily survey, 99.6 percent of people surveyed admitted that members of their family or friends had at some stage driven while drunk.
In recent years, fatal car accidents in Chinese cities have triggered public outcry and rage, with many people calling for stricter penalties for drunk driving.
In July 2009, the Intermediate People's Court of Chengdu in Sichuan Province sentenced a drunk driver named Sun Weiming to death following an auto accident in which he was driving without a license and killed four people, which was the first such verdict in China.
In the second trial, the verdict was changed to life imprisonment.
Sun's case was deemed as "a crime against public security."
In the same month, a drunk driver in Nanjing, capital city of eastern Jiangsu Province, hit nine pedestrians and six cars, leaving five dead including a pregnant woman.
In contrast to the public's call for a tough penalty, the maximum sentence handed out was only a three-year prison term. The judges were constrained by the Criminal Law as it stood then.
Following the cases, the SPC issued a judicial interpretation in September 2009 that instructed local courts in what situations severe sentences should be given to a drunk driver.
- About Us
- |
- Terms of Use
- |
-
RSS - |
- Privacy Policy
- |
- Contact Us
- |
- Shanghai Call Center: 962288
- |
- Tip-off hotline: 52920043
- 沪ICP证：沪ICP备05050403号-1
- |
- 互联网新闻信息服务许可证：31120180004
- |
- 网络视听许可证：0909346
- |
- 广播电视节目制作许可证：沪字第354号
- |
- 增值电信业务经营许可证：沪B2-20120012
Copyright © 1999- Shanghai Daily. All rights reserved.Preferably viewed with Internet Explorer 8 or newer browsers.
